Worth the Consequences.
Small-batch pies, tarts, Scotch scones & confections made by hand with Southern roots, old-world influence, and very little patience for boring desserts.
Beautifully made. Slightly dangerous.
Nightshade & Sugar makes the kind of desserts worth making a special trip for: flaky pies, rich tarts, proper Scotch scones and a few carefully chosen confections. The flavors wander between Southern kitchens and old-world bakeries, with the occasional unruly ingredient thrown in for good measure.
Black Briar Tarts
Blackberry Bakewell tart — sharp blackberry beneath rich almond frangipane and toasted almonds.
Mourning Biscuit
Buttery Scottish-style shortbread darkened with black cocoa. Perfect for tea, coffee, and minor bereavements.
More From the Apothecary
Pick Your Poison
Build a box. Choose any three personal pies + one confection assortment. Mix your poisons however you like.
Heather & Rue
Proper Scotch scones. Plain, London Fog, or Vanilla Veil. Simple, buttery, and best eaten warm.
Seasonal Items
Mourning Biscuit: Funeral Bloom – Black-cocoa shortbread dipped in dark chocolate and finished with tart freeze-dried strawberry.
The menu draws from Southern roots, a childhood spent in Europe, and an unreasonable affection for good pastry. No fondant towers. No mile-high frosting. No desserts designed primarily for Instagram. Just carefully made pies, tarts, scones, and confections with bold flavors, good ingredients, and enough personality to keep things interesting.
How It Works
1 – Choose your poison.
Order from the current menu during the preorder window.
2 – Choose your pickup time.
Select an available Oklahoma City pickup window at checkout.
3 – Show up hungry.
Your order will be baked, packed, and waiting.